Friday, January 18, 2013

New Year, New You # 3 Dietary Guidelines: Establishing Appropriate Nutrient Ratios


The third post in the New Year, New You series is going to focus on explaining different methods used for structuring a diet program.  It is important to be able to correctly establish the right amount of protein, fat, and carbohydrates that the body needs.  These nutrients are collectively referred to as the macronutrients. Before diving into that process a distinction between two different terms needs to be understood: dietary breakdown and nutritional breakdownDietary breakdown is the term for describing the style in which the nutrition of the diet will be defined.  The most common styles of dietary breakdown are; Low-Carb, Fat-Burning, Mass Building, and High-Carb Performance Diet.  Nutritional Breakdown is the target percentages of the macronutrients within the specific type of diet.  These percentages are broken down in ranges and not exact numbers.  This is done on purpose for two reasons: 1) hitting an exact number every day is impossible and, 2) Obsessing about hitting an exact number every day will inevitably lead to more frustration than success.  In light of this, remember, blessed are the imperfectionists for their flexibility will accomplish more.

Before going any further it is appropriate to spend some time coming to an understanding of the nutritional values of the macronutrients.  The macronutrients are measured in two different ways; calories and grams.  Calories measured the amount of energy that food contains.  While grams measure the macronutrient by weight.  This often causes confusion with people that makes it difficult to understand and eat healthy because, not all calories are created equal.
      Protein has 4 calories per 1 gram.
      Carbs also have 4 calories per 1 gram
      Fats contain 9 calories per 1 gram.

Keeping that in mind, we will now move into an explanation of the different styles of dietary breakdown.

Low-Carb Diets
This diet is best for those who are sedentary or lightly active and want to lose weight without strenuous exercise.  A low carb diet is one where less than 30% of the nutrition is consumed from carbohydrates.  More protein and fat must be consumed with this type of diet to ensure that the person is still consuming adequate calories to support the body.
      Pros of a Low Carb Diet
      Fast weight loss for a short period of time
      3-4 weeks for non-exercisers
      4-6 weeks for exercisers
      May help control blood sugar levels for diabetics TALK WITH YOUR DOCTOR BEFORE TRYING A LOW CARB DIET
      Works for both those who exercise and those who do not
      People who are too obese to exercise may be able to lose weight

  Cons of Low Carb Diet
      This dietary method only work for a short period of time
      If cut carbs are cut too low, moodiness and short-temperedness can occur
      Too much fat will ruin this diet
      More protein must be consumed on a low carb diet and when combined with a lack of adequate fiber may lead to severe constipation
      Absolutely no breads, pasta, baked goods, soda, juice or refined sugars for this to work

Typically, diet programs like the Adkins’ or South Beach diets that use low carb methods have two stages with the first stage lasting for 2-4 weeks.  During this stage no breads, pasta, baked goods, soda, juice, refined sugars, or fruit are consumed.  Protein is consumed at every meal, but usually not red meat. Protein sources tend to come from chicken, lean turkey, lean fish, and eggs along with healthy fats such as avocados, nuts, and olive oil.  There should be more vegetables than anything else at each meal.  The second stage is the same as stage one with the addition of fruit at two or three times per day instead of, or with, vegetables and stage two also lasts 2-4 weeks.

The Nutritional Breakdown for a low carb diet typically is broken down as follows: Carbohydrates form 20-35% of the nutrition in this diet, Fat will form up to 20-40% of this diet, and protein will make up the remaining nutrition 25-60% of nutrition for this diet.  To determine these numbers let’s assume that a person needs 2400 calories per day, while exercising to lose 1lb per week.
      Example:
      2400 cal x 20-35% = total daily calories from Carbohydrates
      2400 calories x 20-35% = 480-840 daily calories from Carbs
      2400 x 20-40% = 480-960 calories from Fat
      2400 x 25-60% = 600-1440 calories from Protein

Once the correct calorie range has been determined for each nutrient it can be converted to the grams per day range by dividing by the calories per gram for the respective nutrient.

      480 -840 calories per day divided by four would translate into 120-210 grams of Carbs per day
      480-960 calories divided by 9 would be 53-107 grams of Fat per day
      600-1440 calories divided by 4 would be 150-360 grams of Protein per day

Fat-Burning Diets
This is best suited for people who are moderately, very, or extremely active and are trying to lose body-fat while maintaining muscle mass and strength.  From an exercise standpoint, it is important to note that this method works best for those who incorporate both strength-training and cardio training in their fitness program.  Typically, unless a person is constantly performing High Intensity Interval Training, as the main part of the strength program, then this diet will involve too many Carbs.
      Pros
      More Carbs, more energy
      Better supports regular exercise
      Due to increased physical activity and exercise levels this can be more forgiving and less strict than the low Carb diet
      Cons
      Too many Carbs if you are not exercising and want to lose body fat
      Still no refined sugars, or junk food
      Whole-grain pasta and breads are allowed but strictly controlled, no more than three servings per day

In the nutritional breakdown for fat-burning diets carbohydrates comprise 40-55% of daily calories for this diet, fat ranges between 15-25% of the daily calories, and protein will be 25-35% of daily calories.  To determine these numbers take 2400 calories and multiply by the percentage of each nutrient to develop the range
      Example:
      2400 x 40-55% = total daily calories from carbohydrates
      2400 calories x 40-55% = 960-1320 daily calories from Carbs
      2400 calories x 15-25% = 360-600 calories from Fat
      2400 calories x 25-35% = 600-840 calories from Protein

Converted to grams:
      960-1320 divided by four is 240-330 grams of Carbs per day
      360-600 divided by 9 is 40-67 grams Fat per day
      600-840 divided by 4 is 150-210 grams of Protein per day

Mass Building
This diet starts by properly addressing protein and fat, then carbohydrates.  To determine protein needs identify what body weight that you wish to be.  Eat this many grams of protein per day. Multiply this number by 4 this is the total number of calories per day needed from protein.  Subtract this number from 2600.
      Example protein for a person needing 2600 calories per day, wanting to improve mass to 180lb
      180 x 1 = 180g Protein per day
      180 x 4 = 720 calories per day from Protein
      2600-720 = 1880 calories remaining for the day

To determine the fat requirements, after identifying the correct number of grams of protein, cut this number in half, this is the number of grams of fat that will be needed each day. Multiply the grams of fat by 9 to calculate the total fat calories per day and then subtract this number from what was left after subtracting the protein calories from 2600.
      Example Fat Calculation
      180 x 0.50 = 90 grams of Fat per day
      90 x 9 = 810 calories per day from Fat
      1880-810 = 1070 calories per day remaining

For identifying the correct number of Carbs, take the calorie number remaining after subtracting protein calories and fat calories from 2600 and divide this number by four.  This is the grams of Carbs per day required to meet mass building goals.
      Example Carb Calculation
      1070/4 = 268 grams of carbs per day

In this example a person needing 2600 calories per day to improve body mass to 180lb would need per day: 180g or 720 calories from Protein, 90 or 810 calories from Fat, 268g or 1070 calories from Carbs to reach the goal of improving muscle mass to 180lbs.

High-Carb Performance Diet
Please take note of this: dieting this way is best for endurance athletes wishing to maintain current body weight and composition.  It provides high carbs for energy to maintain performance at a high intensity for a long duration.  Because of this, this method contains far too many carbs for anyone who is not very or extremely active.  The Nutritional Breakdown for this diet has carbs 45-60% of daily calories, protein 15-25% of daily calories, fat 15-30% of daily calories.
      Example:
      A person needs 2800 calories to maintain body weight
      2800 x 45-60% = 1260-1680 daily calories from Carbs
      2800 x 15-25% = 420-700 daily calories from Protein
      2800 x 15-30% = 420-840 daily calories from Fat

Convert to Grams
      1260-1680 divided by four is 315-420 grams of Carbs per day
      420-700 divided by four is 105-175 grams of Protein per day
      420-840 divided by nine is 47-93 grams of Fat per day

What you eat maximizes the potential to achieve the goal.  Eat for the body you want not the body you have.

No comments:

Post a Comment